patching...
Update: Got a news tip? Send the editor an email at christopher.paicely@patch.com
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

Metra Fare Hike By the Numbers: Will You Still Buy the 10-Ride Ticket?

Metra's board voted to drop the discount on its 10-ride ticket. Now it costs the same as 10 individual fares, instead of nine. Tell us what you think of the decision. Plus, Patch breaks down the numbers surrounding the increase.

 

If there's one thing you can say about the increase in Metra's 10-ride ticket, it's that you get what you pay for.

The Metra board of directors voted 8-2 on Friday, Nov. 16, to make the 10-ride ticket cost as much as 10 individual tickets, ABC 7 News reports. Currently, the price of the 10-ride ticket is equal to nine individual tickets.

READ: Check Out the Full ABC 7 News Story for More Details

The increase goes into effect Feb. 1.

Because no one demanded it, Patch breaks down the numbers surrounding the 10-ride fare hike.

How Much the Increase Will Cost Southland Commuters

Metra fares are dependent on distance. Here's how much that 10th ticket will cost for a commuter to travel from his or her home station to downtown Chicago.

  • Beverly, Morgan Park: $4.25
  • Oak Lawn, Palos Hills: $4.75
  • Oak Forest, Tinley Park, Homewood-Flossmoor, Palos: $5.25
  • Mokena, Orland Park, Olympia Fields: $5.75
  • New Lenox, University Park: $6.25
  • Laraway Road (New Lenox), Joliet: $6.75

How Much Are Commuter Fares Across the Country

What are other commuters paying to make it to work? Here's a look at fares in other metro areas. For comparison, the distance between downtown Chicago to Orland Park is 26 miles.

Cities Transit System Distance Fare
Oakland to Fremont (California) Bay Area Rapid Transit (BART) 24 miles $4.05
Washington, D.C. to Rockville, Md. Metro 20 miles $5.75 (during peak hours)
Manhattan to Staten Island (New York) Staten Island Ferry 23 miles Free

SOURCE: Transit authorities

Things You Could Give Up to Pay for That 10th Ticket

  • Grande Gingerbread Latte at Starbucks: $4.75
  • Hamburger at Five Guys: $5.59
  • Two Chili Cheese Dogs from Portillo's: $5.98
  • Renting five Redbox DVDs for a day (or one Redbox DVD for five days): $6
  • 12-inch hot roast beef sandwich at Subway: $6.75
  • Five of the 14 tracks on One Direction's Take Me Home album: $6.45

YOUR TURN: Will you still buy the 10-ride ticket? Or will you just buy nine individual fares? Take our poll and share your thoughts in the comments section.

Get Patched in! Sign up for our newsletters.

Beverly-Mt. Greenwood | Evergreen Park | Oak Lawn | Palos | Orland Park | Tinley Park | Oak Forest | Frankfort | Mokena | New Lenox | Chicago Heights | Homewood-Flossmoor 

  • Will you still buy Metra's 10-ride ticket?

    (Voting has been closed for this question)
    • Yes. Out of convenience.
        9 (26%)
    • No. What's the point?
        25 (73%)
    Total votes: 34
  • Your vote will only count once. This is not a scientific poll. View Results Vote!
Related Topics: 10-Ride Ticket, Commuters, Fare Hike, and Metra

Mr. Jack

8:26 am on Saturday, November 17, 2012

Nice move, Metra. You have now made it cheaper for my family to drive and park downtown, than take the train. Come on. really!? How about a family fare?

Reply

Ben Ghazi

8:49 am on Saturday, November 17, 2012

Metra is just another bloated monopoly. Eliminate that useless SW service that runs infrequently and usually is late. What is the point of taking train to work if you are late?

Aren't they the ones where the CEO embezzled $Millions then offed himself in front of a train ? Classy.

Reply

Tom Brescia

9:39 am on Saturday, November 17, 2012

After a 35% fare increase a year ago. Now another fair increase. Who puts these people on the Metra board and how does the public go about removing them. Maybe Cliff needs to go back where he came from and we need to get someone from the private sector to step in and run this like a business rather than another useless government agency. It's amazing that private companies can run the parking meters, the Skyway and the Indiana Toll Road and make money, but government was losing millions. Take the hint Metra.

Reply

Gehrig

10:32 am on Saturday, November 17, 2012

Every taxpayer/rider on the Rock Island District line should ask Metra how much of the 11% increase is driven by the $1.3 million just given to Oak Forest for a new station, $6.3 million tossed into the 80th Avenue station in Tinley Park with the underpass that has already been vandalized, and the $1.1 million spent to put ding-dong lights at pedestrian overpasses at Tinley Park Oak Park Avenue and Hickory Creek. So when these local mayors say that costs aren't falling on local community taxpayers they are full of you-know-what. The costs are not only falling directly on the taxpaying riders of those communities but the costs are falling on every taxpaying rider on the Rock Island District. So to you Chicagoans and south suburban residents, do you like the fact that Mayor Zabrocki and his band of hooligans just spent so much of YOUR money? How about asking Mayor Kuspa how you will be able to enjoy the new Oak Forest station. And, to those of you riding the Southwest Service Line through Orland Park, what has the 19th Ward South provided to you in exchange for your hard earned money?

Reply
Comment_arrow

David Chambers

2:09 pm on Saturday, November 17, 2012

Excuse me, but the taxpayer/rider you refer to as having price increases falling on them are the very ones who SHOULD be paying for these improvements. Furthermore, the community taxpayers who do not ride Metrarail may share in the costs of these improvements because they benefit as well from improved rail operations. That is the way things work in our United States; everybody pays, the majority benefits. If you do not think this fair, try living in another Westernized, Democratic culture, such as France, Canada, Spain, Italy, Germany, etc. and tell me what your taxes would be living in one of them. I can tell you this much; people who spread misinformation around, shouting about how unfair things are, are usually disgruntled for another reason. Maybe you would feel better if you applied some of that energy towards supporting the efforts of the Occupy movement, which is leading the efforts of Labor (the strikes against Wal Mart), and other big government/big business oligarchic practices. Don't get me wrong, I understand how a fare increase coupled with millions spent in improvements can get someone riled up (?), but after all, it is only right and proper that those who use a system pay through price increases for it's upkeep, even when those improvements will also benefit the community at large. It is how a democratic republic works, my friend. As for the mayors, well, all you need to do is involve yourself locally to change that factor. That is still your right.

Comment_arrow

Baba Wawa

4:50 pm on Saturday, November 17, 2012

I think the "ding-dong lights" at pedestrian overpasses (what's that?) you so affectionately speak of are there for, gee, SAFETY PURPOSES?

Comment_arrow

Ben Ghazi

5:04 pm on Saturday, November 17, 2012

Idiot bells and Ipod'er lights are great but why does it cost 1/4 $ Million for such simple upgrades? Any competent construction company could build for $50K.

Graft.

Comment_arrow

Baba Wawa

9:43 am on Sunday, November 18, 2012

They put them in at other stations. And how do you know they're just ... "simple upgrades"?

Taxpayer Sick

12:05 pm on Saturday, November 17, 2012

Keep building the multi million dollar train stations. Commuter lots half empty now. Put restaurants in them that no one will go eat. Let the Village of Tinley Park call it a destination that people will go to...spend $5000 to decorate it for the holidays. Its a damn train station that people use 5 minutes a day on their WAY to work. No one lingers there after they get off the train. Build a warming/cooling building with a coffe machine and bathrooms. Our goverment at work wasting money and increasing fares.....what a bunch of IDIOTS.

Reply
Comment_arrow

David Chambers

2:30 pm on Saturday, November 17, 2012

Actually, as a world leader the US lags behind most other industrialized nations in repairs and upkeep of its infrastructure. These repairs you rant about are made with a future in mind which doesn't include so many ozone layer-depleting automobiles used to take workers to their jobs. The majority of industrialized nations who have much better public transportation infrastructures have never had the kind of money the US has, which allows us to ignore the vast waste of petroleum products we seem to ignore, which they cannot afford to do. I mean, do you even know what gasoline costs in Europe, or Australia? Every day as I travel the interstates of Northeastern Illinois, I observe that the vast majority of vehicles have only one person in them- the DRIVER! Since the other democratic republics/industrialized nations have invested in their transportation infrastructures they have positioned their populations advantageously, as they will not need to be taxed as much for road upkeep, gas price rises, etc. Take a look at the world holistically, and you will see that working towards the common good is more prevalent in other countries, in many cases, than it is in the 'land of the free,' where mega-corporations rule and government supports that oligarchic, monopolistic fiefdom, Wake up and smell the coffee!

Comment_arrow

Ben Ghazi

5:07 pm on Saturday, November 17, 2012

Anybody seen the 35th White Sox station that took a decade+ to get? it's a shell that cost $11.7 million. Seriuosly If I had $!0 Million the place would look like the Taj Mahal- granite bronze and limestone.

Mary-Jo

1:45 pm on Saturday, November 17, 2012

For people who regularly use the train, I suppose its a convenience factor, but I would buy the 10-ride and use it over the course of several months or even a year. The benefit of buying a 10-ride was a win-win. Metro got to use your money, paid in advance, for a year and you got a free ride. There is no reason I would do that now.

Reply

David Chambers

1:58 pm on Saturday, November 17, 2012

I have a (November 2012) monthly ticket (marked female) which my wife cannot use since she was downsized. If anyone would like to purchase it, the price is going down every day. Check Craigslist for 'Metra Ticket' in South Chicagoland. We really need to recoup whatever we can for bills. Or, you can contact me through this site, if possible.
Thank you!

Reply

AK

3:27 pm on Saturday, November 17, 2012

I haven't taken the metra since the last fare hike. It costs $10.50a day to ride the train now & $6.25 to park at river city & i don't have to wait for an hour for my afternoon train anymore. Thanks Metra!!

Reply
Comment_arrow

laura

4:13 pm on Saturday, November 17, 2012

Just wondering what your costs for gasoline, wear&tear and additional insurance premiums total for driving. Also, do you drive during rush hours (aka: Increase My Blood Pressure, Please ;-) or during off-peak hours. I drove for many years when there wasn't sufficient train service and have ridden the train for more than 20 years. I prefer the train for the simplicity and less stress and think the costs when all totaled actually are cheaper, even with the rate hikes.

Comment_arrow

AK

8:40 pm on Saturday, November 17, 2012

My drive in is during rush hour, my drive home is off peak (part of the reason I prefer driving, I would miss the train home by 5 or 6 min. & have to waste an hour at the station every day waiting for the next one). I drive a 99 corolla, so i get about 40 mpg. There isn't any difference in my car insurance either. I don't mind the traffic as much as I minded the people screaming on their phones or listening to their music without headphones,or with headphones depending on the volume level :). Don't get me wrong , I took Metra for over 15 years. I love the train. I love being able to read or just relax, but it's just not worth it anymore.

Comment_arrow

laura

2:22 pm on Sunday, November 18, 2012

Absolutely I understand and am not criticizing at all! I am SOOO glad Metra introduced quiet cars so I don't gave to listen the the unrelenting and mindless gabbing! Sounds like you might be in the markets, which is exactly the same reason we drove for so many years because the trains didn't accommodate early opens and closes. Glad you've found a way the works for you. Have a great holiday!

Comment_arrow

AK

5:42 pm on Sunday, November 18, 2012

I do! Thank you Laura & you have a great holiday as well! :-)

OakLawnGuy

3:39 pm on Saturday, November 17, 2012

If the late Phil Pagano hadn't plundered Metra funds for years and years, they might not have had to bring on these increases.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Ben Ghazi

5:08 pm on Saturday, November 17, 2012

AMEN! It's the corruption that is killing us Illinois Residents while the cops dole out speeding tickets. Go investigate some REAL crimes ?

cc

7:40 pm on Saturday, November 17, 2012

I also quit taking Metra after the last increase. I now take a bus to the Orange Line which stops right at my building. No more mile walks to the LaSalle St. station (which is only convenient if you work in the south end of the Loop.) My monthly transportation bill is now $86 as opposed to $120, you do the math. I never thought that I'd be getting to work in the same amount of time taking that horrid CTA, but turns out I do, oddly both the bus and the el are pretty much to the minute with their schedules (though that's not what they try to tell you in the media).

Reply

Kelly

7:53 pm on Saturday, November 17, 2012

Isn't there a board meeting, where the public can state their case, prior to the increase? When does this increase take effect? I too find it somewhat amazing the structures that are being built and the money it is costing to build them. We don't need such massive structures. Why didn't Metra incorporate coffee shops/diners inside them, making them multi-functional? With the increased fares, will we get better/more service, especially on the SW Service? I don't mind paying but what I don't understand is why we have a two hour gap between trains in the middle of the day? No other line has that large of a gap, with as many commuters we have on the SW service. Does someone know when and where the Metra Board meeting will be held? If enough people voice real concerns, it may make a difference. Please stop spewing nonsense and think of intelligent ways to solve yet another problem facing us.

Reply

Just the Facts

8:39 pm on Saturday, November 17, 2012

Never ceases to amaze me of how governmental entities try to increase revenue - by increasing prices. Simply financially ignorant. Let's see...My revenue is too low as McDonald's. I know raise the price of the McDouble to $2 - that'll work - Not!

Reply

Stones

11:21 pm on Saturday, November 17, 2012

For those of us who rely on ten-rides, I suggest we no longer buy them. Simply buy one way tickets and bury them in paperwork and printing costs.

Reply

Hernendo RevolveR

12:22 am on Sunday, November 18, 2012

Get used to it! This is only the beginning. Taxes, fees and everything else is going to go up now that the election is over. You voted for it, you OWN it!

Reply
Comment_arrow

James Madison

6:49 pm on Sunday, November 18, 2012

Amen Hernando. Govt workers and low income folks still get free train vouchers, too. Spread the wealth from the workers to the takers...yes we can!

Comment_arrow

Stones

8:49 am on Monday, November 19, 2012

What do Metra fare hikes have to do with the election? Do you honestly think this wouldn't have happened if Mitt Romney won the election?

It's amazing how every topic turns to the same partisan crap.

Bob Levy

9:27 am on Sunday, November 18, 2012

Thanks Ryan for this post.
Look forward to reading more people's thoughts.

My observation is business related, not political.
I am amazed at what appears to be business/finance stupidity.
By (in effect) elminitating the 10-ride ticket, the lost revenue will cause costs to increase.
When traveling, I will now have to buy the ticket on the train if the "self service machine" is down (often)
This will cause the conductors more work then really necessary.
More importatinly, revenue will be lost due to the non use of 10-rides tickets.
I can not remember how many times I lost or forgot the ticket, and had to buy a new one.
For me as an unfrequent rider, my ticket will expire before all 10 rides were used causing the "free" revenue to be lost.

This business issue is the same as a company where my daughter works.
They are losing clients and raising their fee to compensate.
What is happening is more people are leaving and the result is the death sprial.
If the business had reduced the cost, more would stay, and more would join.
Better to get some revenue then lose more! (find other ways to save costs)

Same with the "tax" raises.
When taxes are raised (like ciggarets) people buy where the tax rate is cheaper.
Lower the cost(tax) and more people would stay/buy.
That is NOT a rocket science solution.
Am I unique in this thinking?

Reply
Comment_arrow

James Madison

6:51 pm on Sunday, November 18, 2012

Bob: only incentive to buy a 10 ride anymore will be the expiration date. Ten rides are good for a year, but one ways are only good for ten days? or some short term.

Comment_arrow

Stones

8:51 am on Monday, November 19, 2012

One ways are good for the full year as well.

Comment_arrow

GKJ

12:49 pm on Monday, November 19, 2012

One ways are good for 14 days from date of purchase, not one year.

Comment_arrow

Stones

1:00 pm on Monday, November 19, 2012

GKJ, I'm looking at one in front of me that states "Valid Through JUL 04 '13. It also says "Valid for 1 year from date of sale".

They may have changed the rules since then, seems they do that a lot lately.

Comment_arrow

Paulie Gualtieri

1:02 pm on Monday, November 19, 2012

Stones, one way Metra tickets are good for 14-days only. Taken from the Metra website, "For travel from one station destination to another. One-way tickets are valid for 14 days from the date of purchase, and they are not refundable." It was another easy way to make money that was implemented with the last fare increase.

Comment_arrow

Stones

2:57 pm on Monday, November 19, 2012

Paulie, you're right that is on the website. Just not sure why I have one that says it's good for a year. Good thing it was only a Zone A to go to 35th Street for a Sox game that they didn't collect.

Bob Levy

6:18 am on Monday, November 19, 2012

The year for the 10 ride is part of the reason I have lost the ticket. Even when I was a daily rider, a couple of times I lost the monthly and had to buy a new one - for some strange reason I would always lose the ticket soon after I bought.
Since there is no financial incentive to buy the 10-ride, why bother?

Reply

Chris

10:37 am on Monday, November 19, 2012

There's no longer a benefit to giving Metra your money before you need the product. Now it will be strictly pay-as-you (well, I) -go.

Reply

Candi

1:54 pm on Tuesday, November 20, 2012

Metra - Boo, Hiss on you!! Guess, I'll only be going downtown on weekends until they screw that up too.

Reply

Leave a comment